Bakery
Cakes
All cakes priced as three tier, 9 inch cakes. Larger sizes available upon request.
Chocolate Chocolate- $40
Dark chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, topped with chocolate ganache and a variety of chocolates.
Vanilla Buttercream- $40
Moist vanilla cake layered with homemade vanilla buttercream.
Chocolate Crème Cake- $40
Dark chocolate cake with vanilla cream cheese frosting and topped with our homemade chocolate ganache.
Chocolate Peanut Butter- $42
Dark chocolate cake filled with Amish peanut butter filling, topped with chocolate ganache and peanut butter candies.
Chocolate Blackberry- $42
Dark chocolate cake with homemade blackberry filling, topped with chocolate ganache and fresh blackberries.
Lemon Raspberry- $42
Vanilla cake with homemade red raspberry filling and covered in lemon buttercream.
Strawberries and Cream- $42
Fresh strawberry cake layered with fresh strawberries and vanilla buttercream, topped with fresh strawberries.
Carrot Cake- $42
Homemade carrot cake with spices and pineapple, layered with cream cheese frosting.
Pumpkin Spice- $45
Pumpkin spice cake layered with browned butter cream cheese frosting and topped with candied pecans.
*The Sugar Queen offers 1 and 2-tier buttercream wedding cakes in a variety of flavors. Contact us for a free consultation to discuss prices.
Cookies
$2 each, $10 ½ dozen, $16 dozen
Chocolate Chip
Our signature cookie! A mix of dark and semi-sweet chips, topped with coarse sea salt.
Snickerdoodle
Soft and chewy cinnamon sugar cookie with bits of toffee.
Monster
Oatmeal, peanut butter, M&M’s™, and chocolate chips- what more could you ask for?
Peanut Butter
A classic take on the peanut butter cookie, but double the peanut butter.
Oatmeal Raisin
Chewy oatmeal cookie with soft, vanilla-soaked raisins.
Cheesecake (9-inch)
Vanilla- $45
Our take on the original cheesecake.
Lemon- $45
Tart lemon cheesecake with a sugar cookie crust.
Chocolate Swirl- $48
Vanilla cheesecake swirled with chocolate and topped with a chocolate ganache.
Lemon Raspberry- $50
Lemon cheesecake topped with homemade red raspberry jam.
Caramel Candied Pecan- $50
Browned butter cheesecake topped with homemade salted caramel and candied pecans.
Fresh Strawberry (Seasonal)- $50
Vanilla cheesecake topped with fresh, glazed strawberries and homemade whipped cream.
Fresh Blueberry (Seasonal)- $50
Vanilla cheesecake topped with fresh, glazed blueberries and homemade whipped cream.
Fresh Peach (Seasonal)- $50
Vanilla cheesecake topped with fresh, glazed peaches and homemade whipped cream.
Desserts
Lemon Bars (Ordered by the dozen)- $18
Our homemade lemon filling baked onto a sugar cookie crust.
Dark Chocolate Brownies (Ordered by the dozen)- $18
Rich, moist dark chocolate brownies.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownies (Ordered by the dozen)- $20
Our original brownie with a generous peanut butter swirl.
Chocolate Whoopie Pies (Ordered by the dozen)- $24
Moist, chocolate cookies sandwiched between homemade marshmallow filling.
Pumpkin Whoopie Pies(Ordered by the dozen)- $24
Pumpkin spice cookies sandwiched between homemade cream cheese frosting.
Pies
All pies priced as 9-inch. 6-inch pies available.
Apple- $18
Our original blend of apple and spices baked between two layers of our made-from-scratch pie crust.
Dutch Apple- $18
Our apple pie topped with a thick layer of oatmeal crumbs.
Pumpkin Custard- $16
Our take on the Thanksgiving classic. Homemade pumpkin pie with a custard blend.
Cherry- $18
Delicious, tart cherries baked between two layers of our made-from-scratch pie crust.
Blueberry- $20
A mixture of blueberries and spices baked between two layers of our made-from-scratch pie crust.
Pecan- $20
Loaded with rick, gooey filling and an abundance of pecans.
Peanut Butter- $18
Homemade vanilla pudding topped with Amish peanut butter, peanut butter crumbs, and homemade whipped cream.
Chocolate Peanut Butter- $18
Homemade chocolate pudding topped with Amish peanut butter, peanut butter crumbs, and homemade whipped cream.
Chocolate Cream- $16
Homemade chocolate pudding topped with homemade whipped cream and chocolate crumbs.
Banana Cream- $16
Homemade vanilla pudding mixed with sweet bananas topped with homemade whipped cream.
Coconut Cream- $16
Homemade vanilla pudding mixed with toasted coconut and topped with homemade whipped cream.
Peach (Seasonal)- $20
Fresh, sweet peached baked between two layers of our made-from-scratch pie crust.
Fresh Strawberry (Seasonal)- $20
Fresh, glazed strawberries piled high and topped with fresh, homemade whipped cream.
Fresh Blueberry (Seasonal)- $20
Fresh, glazed blueberries topped with homemade whipped cream.
Fresh Peach (Seasonal)- $20
Fresh, glazed peaches topped with fresh, homemade whipped cream.
*If you’d like to order something you don’t see on the menu, please feel free to contact us.
